PROCESSED meats and super-sweet drinks are the two most dangerous ultra-processed foods, a new study warns.
Researchers found both products were linked to an increased risk of coronary heart disease (CHD) or cardiovascular disease (CVD) compared to others in the same category.
GettyUltra-processed foods are said to make up 57 per cent of the average UK diet[/caption]
But scientists also found that some ultra-processed foods (UPFs) like yoghurt and bread were associated with a lower chance of CVD or stroke.
Author Kenny Mendoza, from Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health in Boston, Massachusetts, said: “This study suggests an adverse role of the consumption of total UPF as part of a dietary pattern in the risk of CVD, CHD, and stroke.
“Specifically, our findings suggest soft drinks and processed meats should be discouraged, given their consistent adverse association with CVD, CHD, and stroke.”
The team studied data collected from questionnaires filled out by almost 207,000 nurses and other health professionals.
They asked participants about their health and diets every two to four years between.
Foods were categorised into four groups – unprocessed/minimally processed, processed culinary ingredients, processed foods, and UPFs.
UPFs, which are often high in sugar, fat, calories and salt and low in fibre, were then further divided into 10 groups based on nutritional composition:
Bread and cereals (sub-groups: breakfast cereals, dark/whole-grain bread, refined-grain bread)
Sauces, spreads, and condiments
Packaged sweet snacks and desserts
Packaged savoury snacks
Sugar-sweetened beverages
Processed red meat, poultry, and fish
Ready-to-eat/heat mixed dishes
Yoghurt/dairy-based desserts
Hard liquors
Artificially-sweetened beverages
Overall, UPF intake was linked to a higher risk of CVD and CHD.
But sugary drinks and processed meats were the two products associated with the highest risk.
This might include deli meats, bacon or sausages, as well as fizzy beverages.
However, it wasn’t the same for all UPFs, as eight of the 10 groups didn’t produce a significantly increased risk.
Researchers even discovered inverse links for CVD and CHD risks for yoghurt, dairy-based desserts and savoury snacks.
Those who ate more ultra-processed bread and breakfast cereals were also less likely to suffer a stroke.
And cereal intake was associated with a lower risk of CVD and CHD, while hard liquor intake was linked to a lower risk of CHD.
This could be due to the higher fibre content of some of these foods, or the fact they are often fortified with vitamins, scientists said.
How ultra processed is YOUR kitchen?
Ultra processed foods (UPFs) were defined by Brazilian researchers who made the NOVA classification system. It breaks foods into groups depending on how processed they are. The most natural foods are in group 1, while the most processed are in group 4.
The groups do not entirely indicate how healthy a food is. However, it does indicate how processed it is – and studies have linked UPFs to a number of diseases.
How does your kitchen compare to the following groups?
Unprocessed or minimally processed foods (group 1)
vegetables and fruits (fresh or frozen)
dried fruits with no added sugar, honey, or oil
grains and legumes (chickpeas, lentils)
meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs
milk without added sugar
plain yogurt with no added sugar
nuts and seeds
spices and herbs
tea, coffee, water
Processed culinary ingredients (group 2)
iodized salt
salted butter
sugar and molasses from cane or beet
honey extracted from combs
syrup from maple trees
vegetable oils crushed from olives or seeds
butter and lard from milk and pork
starches extracted from corn and other plants
vegetable oils with added anti-oxidants
vinegar with added preservatives
Processed foods (group 3)
canned vegetables, fruits, and legumes
fruits in syrup
salted or sugared nuts and seeds
salted cured or smoked meats
canned fish
artisanal breads and cheese
Ultra-processed foods (group 4)
pop and fruit drinks
sweetened yogurt
sweet or savoury packaged snacks (e.g., cookies)
candies and cake mixes
mass-produced packaged breads and buns
margarines and spreads
breakfast cereals
cereal and energy bars
energy drinks
instant soups, sauces, and noodles
poultry and fish nuggets, hot dogs
many ready-to-heat products: pre-prepared pies, pasta, and pizza dishes
They added: “Typical UPFs (e.g. sugar-sweetened beverages, processed meats, and fast foods) are energy-dense and high in added sugars, saturated fats, and sodium – established CVD risk factors.
“Our findings suggest that UPF groups have differential contributions to cardiovascular risk.
“Reducing the content of sodium, saturated fats, added sugars, and cosmetic additives non-essential for human health in wholegrain bread, cold cereals, and some savoury snacks may enhance the otherwise nutritional value of these products.”
The findings were published in the journal The Lancet Regional Health – Americas.
What are the other risks?
UPFs were defined by researchers in Brazil who created the NOVA classification system.
This breaks foods and drinks into four groups based on how processed they are.
Unprocessed or minimally-processed items (group one) include fresh or frozen fruits and vegetables, meat, and milk without added sugar.
Group two, which covers processed culinary ingredients, encompasses salted butter, honey, vegetable oils and vinegar.
Processed foods fall into the third group and include canned products, cured or smoked meats, and artisanal breads and cheese.
And UPFs (group four) covers fizzy drinks, sweetened yoghurt, mass-produced breads, margarine and spreads, and ready meals.
These products often contain ingredients you wouldn’t find in your kitchen, such as colourings, sweeteners and preservatives.
UPFs have industrial ingredients in them, like added fats and sugars, but also additives and emulsifiers
Dr Emily Leeming
This last category has become the target of health campaigners as numerous studies warn of the potential health damage these products can cause.
A 30-year study by Harvard University found that a diet containing too many raises the risk of an early death.
The research, published in the British Medical Journal, found those who ate the most UPFs had a 13 per cent higher risk.
Another, by Central Queensland University in Australia, claimed a highly-processed diet raised the risk of 32 different illnesses.
These included cancers, anxiety, high blood pressure, obesity, type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and CVD.
CVD is a general term for conditions affecting the heart or blood vessels and is usually associated with a build-up of fatty acid deposits in the arteries and an increased risk of blood clots.
Strokes and CHD are types of CVD that can lead to other outcomes like heart attacks and heart failure.
UPFs are said to make up 57 per cent of the average UK diet.
Dr Emily Leeming, a registered dietitian, previously told The Sun: “Ultra-processed foods are foods that are packaged and have industrial ingredients in them, like added fats and sugars, but also additives and emulsifiers.
“They tend to be foods with long lists of ingredients on the back of the pack.”
She said they are best kept to a minimum – but there are several she would avoid in particular.
This includes energy drinks, vegan burgers, plastic cheese squares and biscuits.
Healthy UPF swaps your family will love
BREAKFAST
Swap processed cereal for yoghurt and oats
Swap seeded bread with jam or a bakery sliced loaf with nut butter
LUNCH
Swap ham sandwiches for pasta salad with homemade pesto
Swap crisps for homemade pitta chips
SNACKS
Swap cereal bars for homemade granola bars
Swap dried fruit for fresh fruit
DINNER
Swap supermarket chicken nuggets for homemade chicken nuggets
Swap supermarket pizza for a DIY pizza
Swap a jarred tomato sauce for tinned tomatoes with herbs