In Focus: The AI revolution in education – cheating or winning? (Picture: Getty/metro.co.uk)
When 16-year-old student Fiore realised an English essay was due the next day, his first thought wasn’t to open a book and cram the assignment into an all-nighter.
After all, it’s 2024.
Instead, he got ChatGPT to save his bacon by writing the entire essay for him within seconds. All he had to do was input the assignment criteria, the required number of paragraphs and formatting information before letting the AI chatbot do the rest.
Describing this process as ‘incredibly easy’, Fiore has since submitted at least five essays this way and, he tells Metro.co.uk, has no regrets.
‘I started using ChatGPT because it’s much easier than actually doing work and my grade was already suffering,’ admits the teen. ‘Most of the time the essays are just English assignments that I simply don’t feel like doing, or based off reading material I don’t want to read.’
While ChatGPT generates ‘pretty convincing’ essays, Fiore always proofreads them and occasionally edits a few words so that they sound ‘more organic’. And whatever he’s doing works, he adds, as they’re bringing in better grades, too.
The ChatGPT app has revolutionised work (Picture: Getty)
No regrets
Although many people would fear plagiarism detectors or eagle-eyed lecturers spotting AI-generated essays, Fiore isn’t afraid of getting caught.
In fact, he doesn’t believe that his teachers ‘will go through the effort of checking’ essays for ChatGPT-generated content, saying that his school ‘doesn’t explicitly say anything against AI use’.
And while his parents don’t know he uses ChatGPT for his schoolwork, he doesn’t think they would ‘necessarily care’.
‘I will absolutely be using ChatGPT for assignments to come, English or not,’ the student says adamantly.
It’s a move Chris Carron, CEO of plagiarism detection software company Turnitin, warns against, however. He says that using AI to ‘outsource their homework and essays’, can affect students’ ability to ‘learn or build critical thinking and communication skills’ that will be needed beyond school.
Chris Carron, CEO of Turnitin, warns against using AI chatbots for homework
‘This new shortcut may be tempting in a pinch, but it will set them up for failure in the workplace,’ he tells Metro.co.uk.
However, it could be a little too late. After analysing 200 million essays, Turnitin found that more than one in ten comprised at least 20% AI-generated text. Six million had at least 80% AI content.
Legitimate use
Not all students are using AI to cheat, though – and not are all using ChatGPT, with a range of similar models available including Google’s Gemini. Many view this technology as a tool to assist their studies and enhance their learning.
23-year-old Elizabeth, who is pursuing a master’s degree in journalism, regularly uses ChatGPT in her works. She says the chatbot helps her better understand complex academic reading materials by simplifying hard-to-understand text.
She has also found uses for it in essay writing, inputting paragraphs and asking the AI tool to rephrase her writing to make it ‘more succinct’ – something some may consider cheating, or at least questionable.
The software also helps her find sources when researching essays, adds Elizabeth.
AI chatbots went mainstream in 2022 (Picture: Getty)
‘ I started using it a few months after it came into popular use,’ she tells Metro.co.uk. ‘I was definitely worried about things like plagiarism at first, but mostly when I was talking about it with other people.
I would say I felt conflicted but only before I’d actually seen for myself the ways it would be useful and what its limitations would be.’
Since then, the student has learned how to use the tool responsibly, which her lecturers even discussed in talks.
Elizabeth says the use of AI among her peers is ‘pretty common now’. She’s heard stories of people getting in trouble for misusing the technology and says there’s a sense of shame surrounding such uses.
But she believes there is a fine line between using ChatGPT to inspire essay writing and using it ‘as a substitute for studying or as a shortcut in essay writing’.
Elizabeth continues: ‘I never copy and paste their output, but it gives me a blueprint to go off of to write more clearly.
‘As a student, it helps to have something that can break down very abstract concepts.’
Supporting disabled students
Maya Seth, a 22-year-old public relations executive, was diagnosed with dyslexia when she was 11 and, because of her condition, found it hard to keep pace with reading materials during her design degree.
While Maya received one-to-one support from her university, she also used ChatGPT to comprehend in-depth academic text.
Asking ChatGPT to summarise academic articles enabled her to determine the ‘key points’, she explains. This helped her save time as she could ‘quickly work out if an article was worth reading’ in the first place.
AI can help in a range of situations (Picture: Getty)
‘Studying a creative subject, AI was also a great way to get over creative blocks by using it as a way to make my blank page less blank,’ she says.
‘I didn’t use anything the AI produced, but it was a good thought-provoking starting point.’
But as this technology isn’t always accurate, Maya says it’s important to ‘read the whole article, not just the AI summary’.
She advises: ‘Students can use the tools ethically by being transparent about their AI use and ensuring against misinformation through fact checking with credible sources.’
Since leaving university in 2023, Maya is now exploring ways it can help her in the workplace as part of an AI working group at her company. She adds: ‘I think ChatGPT is a great tool that we all need to work out how to use ethically.’
It’s not just students
Educators can also find uses for AI tools. Last year, education secretary Gillian Keegan said the tech could do the ‘heavy lifting’ for teachers by marking students’ homework and planning lessons.
They are already using AI software for creating annual school reports with the click of a button, and one school has even appointed an AI headteacher
Minty Pester, an art and media lecturer at a Welsh college, says artificial intelligence is allowing him to ‘speed up admin tasks’ and ‘plan units of work’.
Teachers are increasingly using AI too (Picture: Getty)
The technology is also helping him provide students with tailored support, he says.
He explains: ‘AI makes it quick and easy to change the level something is aimed at or to create something new for individuals with specific areas of improvement.’
With AI rapidly transforming the workplace, Minty believes that understanding technology is just as important as maths or digital literacy for students.
He calls it a ‘vital skill’ that allows students ‘to be more creative with their ideas, to explore concepts and find research that they might not have thought to look for’.
‘The idea is to use it as a tool, not to generate work for the student – they still need to demonstrate their own knowledge and understanding for their qualifications,’ he says.
But is it ethical?
While AI is delivering benefits for both students and teachers, there are obvious ethical implications and technical constraints to consider.
Jade McLellan, deputy head pastoral at St Dunstan’s College, believes that educators should teach ‘young people about the ethics of AI development’, helping them understand ‘how to use it, but also limit and control it’.
However, Minty says a potential downside of using AI as an educational tool could be ‘a shift in priorities’.
He warns that some may view AI usage as ‘people getting lazy’ or ‘not holding on to information or having the same level of literacy skill’, just like predictive text may affect someone’s ability to spell on their own.
Minty has also caught students submitting AI-generated work, which he says can result in them being disciplined for plagiarism or ‘losing their whole qualification’.
He says teachers can detect AI-generated essays by looking for ‘change[s] in sentence structure, abundance of adjectives, use of bullet point lists and higher level writing’.
‘I have caught students trying to pass off work as their own that has been created by AI, luckily for them it was spotted before their final submissions so I could let them know that it needed redoing,’ he adds.
‘Students that try and ‘get away’ with a copy and paste assignment tend to put as much effort into their prompts as they do writing their own work, and it shows.’
Jade McLellan, deputy head pastoral at St Dunstan’s College
Because the large language models powering ChatGPT and other AI tools are trained on large datasets, there are also data privacy concerns.
Minty says both students and educators should refrain from entering sensitive information or copyrighted work into these tools.
‘We can get around this by using ‘closed’ AI tools that don’t take or store the inputs such as Microsoft Copilot,’ he adds.
Educators used to more traditional teaching methods may struggle to understand AI technology and use it incorrectly, too.
One professor in Texas ran his students’ essays through ChatGPT to see if the AI chatbot had written them, failing many students after it said ‘yes’. But it turns out ChatGPT was actually lying.
‘Despite the widespread adoption of AI in the classroom, teachers require more support and guidance to identify AI usage and introduce good practices into the classroom,’ says Jason Tomlinson, managing director at edtech company RM Technology.
‘In fact, research by RM Technology found that a third of teachers believe their students have a better understanding of AI than they do.’
When it comes to addressing ‘this knowledge gap’, he says the education system must develop regulatory policies on AI use, collaborate with experts from the private sector and improve the accessibility of teacher training schemes.
And, as 17-year-old Eastbourne College student Reuben Booth found out, AI tools like ChatGPT can generate ‘verbose’ answers that ‘lack practical sense’.
Eastbourne College student Reuben Booth thinks teachers will spot AI-generated content
‘Its responses could therefore be easily noticed by my teachers and it generally doesn’t allow me to access high marks in my work,’ the teenager explains.
‘I once asked Chat GPT to summarise a long document, which I couldn’t apprehend, into bullet points. However, I found that this meant the understanding of the text I gained was limited, leaving me with no choice but to re-trace my steps and make my own bullet points to work out the text adequately.
‘I would opt against using Chat GPT, most notably because it often doesn’t provide me with answers that contain the precision and specific knowledge that the mark schemes require in all my individual subjects.’
Considering both the opportunities and downsides of AI use in education, Chris, CEO of Turnitin, encourages the sector to ‘experiment with leveraging AI in all teacher and student work’.
Doing so will help educators clarify ‘where and how AI can help with productivity or quality of teaching materials’, he says.
He concludes: ‘We’re hearing of significant productivity gains for teachers, creating more time for teaching and working with students.’